If your water heater is under 8 years old and repair costs less than 50% of replacement cost, repair typically makes financial sense. For units over 12 years old with major component failures, replacement usually provides better long-term value and efficiency.
Clear replacement signs include frequent repairs, rusty or discolored water, loud rumbling noises, visible corrosion, or water pooling around the base. In Coloma’s older homes, we often find that aging water heaters connect to deteriorating supply lines that also need attention.
We provide honest assessments based on your specific situation and budget. If your unit can be repaired cost-effectively, we’ll recommend that option. If replacement makes more sense financially, we’ll explain why without using pressure tactics.